How to Make a Fish Bite When Stillwater Fly Fishing

Stillwater Essentials with Phil Rowley
Share:
Table of Contents

Unlike rivers, where the current helps straighten out your line, stillwater fishing relies largely on your presentation. From mastering different retrieves to knowing when to pause, each detail can make or break your chances of a hook up. In this post, we’re sharing essential tips from the Stillwater Essentials Masterclass by Phil Rowley, offering key insights to help you improve your odds of success when fly fishing in lakes and ponds.

Understanding Your Retrieve

One of the most important elements of stillwater fishing is the retrieve. This involves how you move the fly through the water and how you make it appealing to the fish. There are four main components to every retrieve:

  • Length of the pull: How far you pull the line on each retrieve.
  • Speed: The speed at which you pull the line.
  • Cadence or tempo: The rhythm of your pulls.
  • Pause: The crucial pause, where the fly stops and gives predatory fish a chance to strike.

The key to mastering a retrieve is incorporating variation into these elements, as it can mimic the natural movements of prey and trigger fish to bite.

Key Retrieve Techniques

There are several types of retrieves commonly used in stillwater fly fishing, and each serves a specific purpose. Let’s explore the most popular ones:

Hand Twist

The hand twist retrieve is ideal for moving flies slowly through the water, giving them a natural, erratic movement. This retrieve is perfect for imitating small prey like nymphs. By alternating which fingers you use to pull the line, you can vary the speed and length of each pull. The result is a gentle, herky-jerky motion that mimics the real-life movement of aquatic insects.

Pinch Strip

For those looking to move their flies slowly but struggle with the coordination needed for a hand twist, the pinch strip retrieve is an excellent alternative. This method involves pinching the line between your thumb and forefinger, then pulling it in short, controlled motions. It ensures that you don’t move your fly too quickly, which is essential when targeting slow-moving species like trout.

Strip Retrieve

The strip retrieve is one of the most versatile techniques and is used across various fishing environments. Whether you prefer long, slow pulls or quick, choppy movements, the strip retrieve can be adjusted to suit the fish’s behavior. However, it’s important to avoid pulling the line too fast, as this can appear unnatural to the fish.

Rolly Polly

If you need to speed things up, the rolly polly retrieve is the go-to method. This fast-paced retrieve involves placing the rod under your armpit and pulling the line back quickly with both hands. It’s a great way to trigger an aggressive response from fish that aren’t actively feeding but are reacting to the fast-moving fly. This technique is particularly effective in cold weather since your hands don’t need to touch the wet line as much.

Incorporate the Hang

One trick that can increase your success is incorporating the hang at the end of your retrieve. As you near the end of your retrieve, slowly raise the rod to lift the fly through the water column. This movement often entices the following fish to bite, as it changes the angle and speed of the fly, flipping their “kill switch” and prompting an attack.

Cover More Water

When fishing stillwaters, it’s crucial to cover as much water as possible. This can increase your chances of finding fish, especially in larger lakes. The best way to do this is by fan casting, which involves casting at different angles in front of you. Imagine the face of a clock – cast at 11 o’clock, 12 o’clock, 1 o’clock, and so on. By spreading your casts across different sections, you’ll increase your odds of encountering active fish.

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, fly fishing on lakes may require a bit more effort than on rivers, but with the right techniques, it can be incredibly rewarding. Mastering your retrieve, incorporating the hang, and covering plenty of water are key strategies that can dramatically improve your success. For more in-depth lessons on stillwater fly fishing, check out Phil Rowley’s Essential Stillwater Masterclass, available on Anchored Outdoors.

Not signed up to Anchored Outdoors yet? Join today to access expert-led courses, exclusive tutorials, and tips that will take your fishing skills to the next level!

Picture of Anchored Outdoors

Anchored Outdoors

Anchored Outdoors is an ever-growing network of fly fishing experts who’ve been brought together by podcaster and fellow outdoorswoman, April Vokey.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Related Stories

When it comes to fishing flies that truly perform, the NearNuff Crayfish stands out as one of the most versatile and effective patterns you can learn. Originally designed by the late Dave Whitlock, this pattern has been carried forward by fly tying expert Allen Rupp.
Andy Weiner is a passionate fly angler and the author of Down By the River⁠, an award-winning children’s book that celebrates the joys of fly fishing and family. In this episode of Anchored, we dive into his story—the one beyond the pages.
Recently, expert angler and author Phil Rowley sat down with us to share why trout remain his favorite species to fish, and why they continue to hold such a special place in the fly fishing world.